medicolegal death investigation
Source: The Law Gazette
Most countries have legal procedures for investigating the cause of death in cases where death has occurred in suspicious circumstances, or in which the cause of death is apparently unknown or unnatural.
In England and Wales this is the 'Coronial System', whilst in Scotland such deaths are investigated by the Procurator Fiscal. In the US, many states have a coroner, whilst in others a 'Medical Examiner' system is in operation.
In England and Wales approximately 200,000 deaths a year are reported to the coroner. Not all are referred for post mortem examination; however, an autopsy will be carried out in all cases where there are any suspicious circumstances, or suspected criminal involvement, as well as suicides, accidents and sudden or unexpected deaths.
If a body is found where no doctor has been in attendance, the police will investigate and refer the case to the coroner. If there are no suspicious circumstances, the police involvement will usually cease. Any doctor may be called upon to confirm 'life-extinct', and in some countries that same doctor may also be able to issue a death certificate if he/she is satisfied from the history and circumstances surrounding the death. In this country, a doctor who has recently treated the deceased may issue a certificate if he/she believes that the death was due to the condition being treated by them, but if there is any doubt, they should refer the death to the coroner without issuing a certificate.
In the larger metropolitan areas, such as London, Forensic Medical Examiners (FMEs), who are doctors specialising in clinical forensic medicine, may be the first person to attend a death, and they will determine whether the coroner should be informed.
the coroner and reporting deaths
The New York morgue - identification (Corbis)
The coroner holds an office with a long history - dating back to the 12th Century.
Coroners in England and Wales are legally qualified, but not necessarily medically qualified, except in some large jurisdictions.
The coroner is employed by the city or county administration to enquire into certain types of death. Cases are referred to him/her by the police, the Registrar for Births, Deaths and Marriages, as well as hospital doctors and GPs.
Deaths referred to the coroner include:
- where the deceased was not attended in his last illness by a doctor,
- where the deceased was not seen by a doctor either after death or within 14 days prior to death,
- where the cause of death is unknown,
- where death appears to be due to industrial disease or poisoning,
- where death may have been unnatural or have been caused by violence or neglect or abortion or attended by suspicious circumstances,
- where death has occurred during surgical operation or before recovery from an anaesthetic.
Doctors in England and Wales have no legal obligation to report cases to the coroner, but there is an ethical obligation to do so, and indeed there has developed a convention that they will not issue a death certificate if they intend to report a case to the coroner.
The coroner has several options open to him/her upon receiving details of a death,
- request the doctor to issue a death certificate, and carry out no further enquiries into the matter,
- direct a pathologist to carry out an autopsy (and then issue a certificate if the pathologist indicates that death was due to natural causes),
- hold an 'inquest' into the circumstances surrounding the death.
Unexpected or violent deaths are investigated in other jurisdictions by medical examiners, for example in some States in the USA, who are often (but not invariably) forensic pathologists.
Can a coroner be sacked? Yes, but this is a rare occurrence - see for example, the coroner for Avon (UK)
the coroner's post mortem examination report
Pathologists in England and Wales making post mortem examinations on behalf of the coroner report their findings to the coroner in a wide variety of formats; there is no set 'protocol'.
The quality of reports made following coroners post mortem examinations has been criticised by the National Confidential Enquiry into Patient Outcome and Death (NCEPOD) - in their 2006 report 'The coroner's autopsy: do we deserve better?' - where one in four reports was considered poor or unacceptable.
Examples of reports are not easy to find on the internet, in view of the fact that reports of examinations made for the coroner are not to be supplied to any person other than the coroner, unless authorised by the coroner (Coroners Rules 1984 rule 10(2)). The report made by Dr Nicholas Hunt following his examination of the body of David Kelly has, however, been made public, and can be read at the Guardian newspaper's website. Whilst this report reflects the type of report made following forensic post mortem examinations in England and Wales, it is more detailed than those reports produced following 'routine' coroner's post mortem examinations.
The taint of the tavern-parlour vitiated the evidence, ruined the
discretion of the jurors, and detracted from the dignity of
the coroner. The solemnity of the occasion was too
generally lightened by alcohol or entirely nullified by the
incompetency of the judge. In short, the tribunal designed
by Edward I. to be one of the most important in his kingdom,
whose presidency was to be held by a knight " of the most
meet and most lawful men of the county," had been univer-
sally degraded to a dreary farce, stage-managed by a foolish
beadle, where the legal administration was ignominiously
known as " crowner's quest law " — a thing proverbially to be
laughed at, and where the majesty of death evaporated with
the fumes from the gin of the jury.
The Life and Times of Thomas Wakely. Sir Samuel Squire Sprigge 1897
(Thomas Wakely 1795-1862 Coroner of West Middlesex argued for medical coronerships)
coroners and inquests in history - selected references
- Getting away with murder? The supression of coroners' inquests in early Victorian England and Wales. Fisher P Local Population Studies 2007; (78):47-62 (http://bit.ly/8JeEhw)
- Getting away with murder? Homicide and the coroners in nineteenth-century London. Emmerichs MB. Social Science History 2001; 25(1): 93-100
- Medicolegal progress in inquests of felonious deaths: Westminster, 1761-1866. Greenwald GI, Greenwald MW, Journal of Legal Medicine 1981; 2:193-264 (http://bit.ly/7y96VV)
- Reporting murder: Fiction in the archives in early modern England, Gaskill M, Social History 1998; 23:1-30
- Legal medicine in history. Clark M, Crawford C (1994)
- The detection of secret homicide: a study of the medico-legal system of investigation of sudden and unexpected deaths, Havard JDJ (1960) and book review in the Cambridge Law Journal 1961;19:251-255
English legal system - historical film from the British Council (1946)
lawyers guide to forensic medicine
Law for medical students, and forensic medicine for law students
|By||Dr Richard Jones|
Law teaching for medical students & forensic medicine teaching for law students
If you are a medical student, what teaching (if any) did you receive on the law? If you did have law teaching, was it medical law, or did it include an introduction to the legal system operating in your country? How was this teaching delivered?
If you are a law student, have you received any teaching on forensic medicine or pathology? Who was this taught by? Was it useful?
the law - student resources
- British and Irish Legal Information Institute (BAILII) - case law
- the English Legal system - student guide
- overview of the law (Open University) and justice portal
- Law dictionary
- Law dictionary and explanatory notes (Duhaime.org)
- wikicrimeline - general law resources
- law portal (Wikipedia)
- criminal justice portal (Wikipedia)
- Key cases in medical law
- law flashcards
- Multiple choice questions (MCQs)
- study guides
- case law
- Statute law
- lawbore.net - student resources
- Unlocking the law (Hodder Arnold)
- English law - revision MCQs, essays and mp3s
- Criminal law - MCQs
- the Law Commission - murder
- the Judiciary
the 'pub inquest' and Charles Dickens (1812-1870)
Charles Dickens was a notable critic of the practice of holding coroner's inquests in public houses. Read his short article in Household Words, 'A Coroner's Inquest' (p.109) or his description of an inquest in the Sol's Arms pub in 'Bleak House' (Chapter 11).